In the world of musical theatre, few shows can match the enduring appeal of Lerner and Loewe’s "Brigadoon" and Rodgers and Hammerstein’s "Flower Drum Song". Despite their age, these musicals continue to captivate audiences, proving that timeless stories and melodies can transcend time. But what makes these revivals so compelling? It's not just nostalgia, but a deeper appreciation for the music and storytelling that has stood the test of time.
"Brigadoon", a romantic fantasy about two Americans who stumble upon a mystical Scottish village, is a prime example of a musical that has aged gracefully. The revival at Pasadena Playhouse showcases a Broadway-level production that may be the best local staging of a musical in my 20 years of covering the scene for The Times. The fresh adaptation by playwright Alexandra Silber works remarkably well, modernizing the story while retaining its charm. The dynamic singing and dancing, coupled with a 22-piece orchestra, bring the musical to life, making it a must-see experience.
On the other hand, "Flower Drum Song" is a more complex story. It's a groundbreaking musical that provided a showcase for Asian American performers, but it has struggled to find its place in the modern era. The revival, produced by East West Players and the Japanese American Cultural and Community Center, aims to provide a deeper authenticity and a more genuine reflection of Asian American experience. However, the update falters between eras, and the musical comedy tends to traffic in amusing caricatures. The tension between the update's good intentions and the tendency of musical comedy to simplify and stereotype is evident, leaving the community at once grateful for representation and uncomfortable with the reinforcement of old tropes.
Despite these challenges, both revivals offer a unique opportunity to appreciate the music and storytelling of these timeless musicals. The Pasadena Playhouse revival of "Brigadoon" and the East West Players revival of "Flower Drum Song" are must-see experiences for anyone who loves musical theatre. They showcase the power of music and storytelling to transcend time and connect audiences across generations.
